Doing an analytics showdown on the site here between a few services to see which one shall win for 2025.
Tinylytics
My current provider of some of the juicy info (and provider of the fancy kudos) buttons. It gets the job done, but I’d love to see more info.
Goatcounter
Offers more information, has a sweet craigslist-era aesthetic, and could be self hosted if I want.
Umami
My current front runner in all honesty. Has everything I want, and then some, and is being selfhosted by me right now. Does what I need it to do and I think will win.
If I switch however, I’m going to have to reimplement my upvote buttons somehow but that’s a problem for future me.
Update
Umami self-hosted won.